Comparing 9, the short, and 9, the full-length movie


 The 9 short film (2005), directed by Shane Acker, is a visually powerful post-apocalyptic story that relies on its eerie atmosphere and striking visuals to tell the story. The plot is simple but effective, focusing on the character 9 as he faces a deadly machine in a quiet, lifeless world. There isn’t much character development, but you can see that 9 is brave and curious. The animation is very detailed, with rough textures and a dark, mechanical look that makes the world feel bleak and mysterious. Acker’s style uses shadows, light, and sounds like clanking metal to build tension. The short film has no dialogue, which makes it feel mysterious and adds to the sense of danger.

The full-length 9 (2009) takes the short film’s idea and expands it into a longer story. It explains more about the post-apocalyptic world and introduces several other characters like 1, 7, and 5. The plot explores bigger themes, such as survival and sacrifice, as the group fights against an evil machine army. Each character has their own personality, but some don’t feel very developed, and their stories seem rushed. The animation in the full-length movie is smoother and more polished, and the environments feel more detailed. However, the movie includes a lot of dialogue and traditional storytelling, which changes the feeling of the story. It loses some of the mysterious and haunting style that made the short film special.

When comparing the two, the short film stands out because it’s simple and focused. It uses silence and visuals to tell its story and creates a strong sense of tension and mystery. The full-length movie, on the other hand, spends more time explaining the world and characters. This adds depth but takes away some of the original short’s charm. The short film is more artistic, while the full-length movie feels more like a regular animated movie. I enjoyed the short film more because it left a stronger impression with its haunting atmosphere and unique storytelling. The full-length movie was still interesting, but it felt more predictable. Both versions are good in their own way, but the short film felt more powerful and memorable to me.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

CCR blog

Image
  1. How does your product use or challenge conventions AND how does it represent social groups or issues?  My friends and I chose to defy genre traditions for our music video. During the research process, I looked at various rap songs' music videos, specifically those by the same artist (Tyler, The Creator). Because Tyler, the Creator, is such a well-known artist, my initial assumption was that I could base our music video on his general themes. Tyler has a very unique way of producing music videos with surprising outfits and outlandish setups. For example, in the music video “See You Again” Tyler has a set on a naval ship and a small boat at sea, so the idea of trying to make our video similar to Tyler’s music videos was abandoned. That would ultimately be unattainable for my group. We didn't have any money to spend on costumes, sets, or activities. This is why we decided to focus on the fundamentals of our relationships. Friendship. Rather than creating a video about money,...
Read more

Peer review blog

Image
Reviewer #1 The first reviewer praised the foreshadowing at the start of the sequence, when the kidnapper is visible in the distance behind Jasmine. She also enjoyed the scenario with the empty swing, which led to the kidnapping. However, she admitted that she didn't really get the concept of Jasmine's revenge in the last scene. I believe this is due to our decision not to have Imani hold a knife in that scenario for safety reasons. I don't think we'll solve it, but we'll compensate with voiceover.  Reviewer #2 The second reviewer said they enjoyed the entire movie. They did not suggest any specific improvements. However, they noted that the second part of the sequence appeared to be a little off. They said it was more unprofessional than the first. Reviewer #3 The third critic stated that they loved the actors' facial expressions. They did express a desire to hear additional diegetic sound throughout the sequence to break up the music played. They believed that...
Read more